Introduction to "Working Across Species"

Mason Dentinger, Rachel and Woods, Abigail (2018) Introduction to "Working Across Species". History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 40 . p. 30. ISSN 0391-9714

Full content URL:

Introduction to "Working Across Species"
Published Open Access Manuscript
2018 Dentinger Woods working across sps.pdf - Whole Document
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.

Item Type:Article
Item Status:Live Archive


Comparison between different animal species is omnipresent in the history of science and medicine but rarely subject to focussed historical analysis. The articles in the ‘‘Working Across Species’’ topical collection address this deficit by
looking directly at the practical and epistemic work of cross-species comparison. Drawn from papers presented at a Wellcome-Trust-funded workshop in 2016, these papers investigate various ways that comparison has been made persuasive and successful, in multiple locations, by diverse disciplines, over the course of two centuries. They explore the many different animal features that have been considered to be (or else made) comparable, and the ways that animals have shaped science and medicine through the use of comparison. Authors demonstrate that comparison between species often transcended the range of practices typically employed with experimental animal models, where standardised practises and apparatus were applied to standardised bodies to produce generalizable, objective
data; instead, comparison across species has often engaged diverse groups of nonstandard species, made use of subjective inferences about phenomena that cannot be directly observed, and inspired analogies that linked physiological and behavioural characteristics with the apparent affective state of non-human animals. Moreover,
such comparative practices have also provided unusually fruitful opportunities for collaborative connections between different research traditions and disciplines.

Keywords:comparison, animals, medicine, biology, history
Subjects:V Historical and Philosophical studies > V380 History of Science
Divisions:College of Arts
ID Code:41496
Deposited On:17 Jul 2020 08:42

Repository Staff Only: item control page