The effect of contextual information on decision-making in forensic toxicology

Hamnett, Hilary and Dror, Itiel (2020) The effect of contextual information on decision-making in forensic toxicology. Forensic Science International: Synergy . ISSN 2589-871X

Full content URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fsisyn.2020.06.003

Documents
The effect of contextual information on decision-making in forensic toxicology
Authors' Accepted Manuscript
[img]
[Download]
[img]
Preview
PDF
Hamnett & Dror -Toxicology Decision Making.pdf - Whole Document

782kB
Item Type:Article
Item Status:Live Archive

Abstract

The impact of cognitive bias on decisions in forensic science has been demonstrated in
numerous disciplines such as DNA and fingerprints, but has not been empirically
investigated in the more objective domains, such as forensic toxicology. In the first
experiment, participants (n= 58) were affected by irrelevant case information when
analysing data from an immunoassay test for opiate-type drugs. In the second experiment,
participants (n=53) were biased in their choice of tests, for example, the age of the
deceased impacted testing strategy: for older people, medicinal drugs were commonly
chosen, whereas for younger people drugs of abuse were selected. Based on the results
that examiners analyzing case data may have biases if they are given access to case
context, we propose that examiners analysing presumptive test data are blind to irrelevant
contextual information. Furthermore, that forensic toxicology laboratories use a protocols
consistent, and that any deviations are documented and justified.

Keywords:Cognitive bias, contextual bias, forensic toxicology, case strategy, human factors
Subjects:C Biological Sciences > C850 Cognitive Psychology
F Physical Sciences > F410 Forensic Science
Divisions:College of Science > School of Chemistry
ID Code:41195
Deposited On:08 Jul 2020 09:53

Repository Staff Only: item control page