Harnessing Emotion to Inform Clinical Nursing Judgement

Mckinnon, John (2019) Harnessing Emotion to Inform Clinical Nursing Judgement. In: North Yorkshire Research Forum, 2nd April 2019, School of Nursing, Barber House, University of Sheffield.

Full content URL: http://clahrc-yh.nihr.ac.uk/our-themes/translating...

DocumentsImages
Harnessing Emotion to Inform Clinical Nursing Judgement
Background Clinical judgement is the application of evidence to decision making in a professional healthcare setting. Studies in neuroscience (Immordino -Yang and Damassio, 2007) have shown that effective judgement requires emotion to provide a guiding ‘rudder’ revealing knowing to be a feeling state. Emotional labour as a central feature of nursing practice is well documented (Theodosius, 2008). Theorists have identified emotions as tools for reflection (Bradbury-Jones et al. 2009), but this area of knowledge is preoccupied with self awareness and therefore underdeveloped. Aims This paper presents evidence of the existence of a commonality of emotions in nursing practice with potential as a framework of core emotion concepts arising from diverse narratives for use as tools for reflection and professional judgement. Method In phase one thirty-three nurses across five specialist areas talked exhaustively about the emotions they experienced while immersed in practice and the causes of these emotions. The data was collected in a London teaching hospital NHS trust and in three community NHS trusts in the East Midlands of England. Following this, in a second phase, six nurses (two supervisors and four supervisees) in a London Teaching Hospital who had not taken part in the first part of the research talked about their experience after two months and four months of using a framework for reflection consisting of seven common core concepts identified in the first research phase. In both phases the interviews were audio-taped, transcribed verbatim and the data analysed using Grounded Theory Method. Results The data revealed professional movement that was characterised by person centred care in the face of complex adversity. Seven core emotional concepts were found to have commonality across practice forming an ‘emotion map’. The ‘emotion framework’ for reflection was shown to increase self awareness, inform and empower practice Discussion The design is limited by the singularity of discourse and the sample size. The notion of emotional constituents of a framework for reflection opens up a new frontier in learning in which the details of an experience are the outcome of reflection on an emotion rather than the reverse. The framework demonstrated ‘organic’ properties which permit a harnessing of the sense of salience that is central to human judgement. Increased credence has been given to personal knowledge and intuition. References Bradbury- Jones, C., Hughes S.M., Murphy, W., Parry, L. and Sutton, J. (2009) A new way of reflecting in nursing: the Peshkin Approach. Journal of Advanced Nursing. 65(11):2485-2493 Immordino-Yang, M.H.,Damasio, A. (2007) We Feel , Therefore We Learn: The Relevance of Affective and Social Neuroscience to Education. Mind, Brain and Education. 1(1):3-10 Theodosius, C. (2008) Emotional Labour in Health Care: the unmanaged heart of nursing. Oxon Routledge.
[img]
[Download]
[img] Microsoft PowerPoint
Harnessing Emotion to Inform Nursing Judgement.pptx - Presentation

2MB
[img]
Preview
Image (JPEG)
John_Mckinnon_lecture.jpg - Supplemental Material

531kB
Item Type:Conference or Workshop contribution (Lecture)
Item Status:Live Archive

Abstract

Harnessing Emotion to Inform Nursing Practice

Background

Studies in neuroscience (Immordino -Yang and Damassio, 2007) have shown that effective judgement requires emotion to provide a guiding ‘rudder’ revealing knowing to be a feeling state. Emotional labour as a central feature of nursing practice is well documented (Theodosius, 2008). Theorists have identified emotions as tools for reflection (Bradbury-Jones et al. 2009) but this area of knowledge is preoccupied with self-awareness and therefore underdeveloped.

Aim
This paper presents evidence of the impact of a new framework which harnesses emotion to inform nursing practice.

Method
In phase one thirty-three nurses across five specialist areas talked exhaustively about the emotions they experienced while immersed in practice and the causes of these emotions. The data was collected in a London teaching hospital and in three community NHS trusts in the East Midlands of England. Following this, in a second phase, six nurses (two supervisors and four supervisees) in a London Teaching Hospital who had not taken part in the first part of the research talked about their experience after two months and four months of using a framework consisting of seven concepts identified in the first research phase. In both phases the interviews were audio-taped, transcribed verbatim and the data analysed using Grounded Theory Method.

Results
Seven core emotional concepts were found to have commonality across practice forming an ‘emotion map’. The ‘emotion framework’ was shown to increase self-awareness, inform and empower practice.

Conclusion
The framework opens up a new frontier in learning for which the details of an experience are the outcome of reflection on emotion rather than the reverse. The framework demonstrated ‘organic’ properties which permit a harnessing of a sense of salience that is central to clinical judgement in nursing. Increased credence has been given to personal knowledge and intuition in nursing practice.

Keywords:Emotion, Judgement, Nursing theory, neuroscience
Subjects:B Subjects allied to Medicine > B700 Nursing
Divisions:College of Social Science > School of Health & Social Care
ID Code:40130
Deposited On:17 Apr 2020 15:17

Repository Staff Only: item control page