Comparing hospital quality performance estimates based on different patient-reported outcome measures

Bojke, Chris, Godoy Caballero, Ana Luisa and Gutacker, Nils (2013) Comparing hospital quality performance estimates based on different patient-reported outcome measures. In: 20th Public Economics Meeting, 31 Jan - 01 Feb 2013, Seville.

Full text not available from this repository.

Item Type:Conference or Workshop contribution (Presentation)
Item Status:Live Archive


Generic as well as disease‐specific PROMs have been collected by hospital providers in the English National Health Service (NHS) since April 2009 for four elective procedures: hip and knee replacement, varicose vein surgery and hernia repair. These measures provide information about the self‐assessment of patients’ health status. The aim of this study is to compare the provision of health services in the NHS according to the different patient‐reported outcome (PRO) measures and to analyse whether our judgement about hospital performance depends on the choice of PRO instrument. In order to do that we carry out a literature review searching for papers that make direct comparisons between the generic, EQ‐5D or EQ‐VAS, and specific measures OHS, OKS or AVVQ. In addition, we estimate fixed effects models for 20,509 patients related in 153 hospitals who have completed the questionnaires before and after hip replacement. This methodology will allow for the analysis of hospital effects, i.e. the variation in the measures at provider level. The results show a high positive correlation (over 0.70) between the measures indicating that in general high/low scores in one of the measures are associated to high/low scores in the other measure used for comparisons. However, there are some hospitals judged outliers according to one measure but not the other one.

Keywords:patient outcomes, PROMs, hospital quality, multilevel modelling
Subjects:L Social studies > L431 Health Policy
L Social studies > L110 Applied Economics
Divisions:College of Social Science > School of Health & Social Care
ID Code:12951
Deposited On:16 Jan 2014 10:58

Repository Staff Only: item control page