Images of the dead: ethics and contemporary art practice

O'Neill, Mary (2011) Images of the dead: ethics and contemporary art practice. In: Cultural and ethical turns: interdisciplinary reflections on culture, Politics and Ethics. Inter-Disciplinary Press, Oxford, pp. 129-136. ISBN 9781848880542

Documents
cpe2ever1120211.pdf
[img]
[Download]
Request a copy
[img] PDF
cpe2ever1120211.pdf - Whole Document
Restricted to Repository staff only

1MB

Official URL: http://www.inter-disciplinary.net/wp-content/uploa...

Abstract

In this chapter I will discuss death in the museum in the form of exhibitions of photographic images of the dead focusing on ‘The Morgue’ (1992), by Andreas Serrano, and ‘Life before Death’ by Walter Schels and Beate Lakotte, exhibited at the Welcome Collection (WC) in 2008. In recent years there have been a number of exhibitions that have presented us with photographs of the dead that have instigated and contributed to discussions concerning the role of art and the appropriateness of photographing the dead, and have highlighted cultural sensitivities concerning the treatment of the corpse. These exhibitions are often discussed in relation to ethical considerations; however, I will posit the argument that the ‘ethical turn’ in discussions of contemporary art is often an avoidance of difficult subjects rather than an engagement with them. To elucidate some of the issues involved in public perceptions of the ethical issues involved in the display of the dead and images of the dead, I will explore two exhibitions that took place in Manchester in 2008. Gunther Von Hagen’s ‘Body Worlds 4’ exhibition took place at the Museum of Science and Industry (MOSI), while at the same time the Manchester Museum (MM) (in the university) covered some of the mummies in their Egyptian display - the unwrapped mummy of Asru and a partially wrapped child mummy - in order to raise issues about the ethics of showing human remains. Both exhibitions had a stated educational purpose though these were framed differently. In the longer version of this chapter I also discuss the appropriation of the dead through a discussion of the funeral in Uppsala Cathedral in 2002 of Fadima Sahindal, a 26 woman of Kurdish decent who was shot by her father because she persisted in a relationship of which he disapproved, exemplifies Durkheim’s assertion that public ritual reinforces common values and social integration. It is precisely the concept of integration that was one of the principle elements of ‘social glue’ that was being preserved in the Swedish establishment’s response to the murder.

Item Type:Book Section
Additional Information:In this chapter I will discuss death in the museum in the form of exhibitions of photographic images of the dead focusing on ‘The Morgue’ (1992), by Andreas Serrano, and ‘Life before Death’ by Walter Schels and Beate Lakotte, exhibited at the Welcome Collection (WC) in 2008. In recent years there have been a number of exhibitions that have presented us with photographs of the dead that have instigated and contributed to discussions concerning the role of art and the appropriateness of photographing the dead, and have highlighted cultural sensitivities concerning the treatment of the corpse. These exhibitions are often discussed in relation to ethical considerations; however, I will posit the argument that the ‘ethical turn’ in discussions of contemporary art is often an avoidance of difficult subjects rather than an engagement with them. To elucidate some of the issues involved in public perceptions of the ethical issues involved in the display of the dead and images of the dead, I will explore two exhibitions that took place in Manchester in 2008. Gunther Von Hagen’s ‘Body Worlds 4’ exhibition took place at the Museum of Science and Industry (MOSI), while at the same time the Manchester Museum (MM) (in the university) covered some of the mummies in their Egyptian display - the unwrapped mummy of Asru and a partially wrapped child mummy - in order to raise issues about the ethics of showing human remains. Both exhibitions had a stated educational purpose though these were framed differently. In the longer version of this chapter I also discuss the appropriation of the dead through a discussion of the funeral in Uppsala Cathedral in 2002 of Fadima Sahindal, a 26 woman of Kurdish decent who was shot by her father because she persisted in a relationship of which he disapproved, exemplifies Durkheim’s assertion that public ritual reinforces common values and social integration. It is precisely the concept of integration that was one of the principle elements of ‘social glue’ that was being preserved in the Swedish establishment’s response to the murder.
Keywords:art and ethics, photography, human remains, informed consent, Life before Death, mummies, Schels, Lakotta, Serrano, The Morgue
Subjects:W Creative Arts and Design > W100 Fine Art
Divisions:College of Arts > Lincoln School of Art & Design
ID Code:4144
Deposited By: Mary O'Neill
Deposited On:06 Mar 2011 20:04
Last Modified:13 Mar 2013 08:56

Repository Staff Only: item control page