Quality criteria in educational research: is beauty more important than popularity?

Karran, Terence (2011) Quality criteria in educational research: is beauty more important than popularity? In: Companion to research in education. Springer. ISBN 1412930383

Documents
Karran_T2011a.doc
[img]
[Download]
Request a copy
Karran_T2011a.pdf
[img]
[Download]
Request a copy
[img] Microsoft Word
Karran_T2011a.doc
Restricted to Repository staff only

109Kb
[img] PDF
Karran_T2011a.pdf
Restricted to Repository staff only

93Kb

Abstract

During the past decade, as national governments (more particularly in the USA and the UK) have scrutinised more closely the cost effectiveness and impact of research funding within higher education, they have become critical of the overall quality of educational research, in terms of its scientific rigour, its utility for practitioners and the manner in which it is assessed. This study addresses the reasons why the quality of educational research was questioned, and then examines the discussion framework for assessing quality which emerged. Following from this, the merits of possible internal and external criteria for the worth of educational research are considered. The links between these criterial sets and the function and purpose of qualitative and quantitative approaches to educational research are analysed. Finally, the question of whether educational research is an art or a science is addressed.

Item Type:Book Section
Additional Information:During the past decade, as national governments (more particularly in the USA and the UK) have scrutinised more closely the cost effectiveness and impact of research funding within higher education, they have become critical of the overall quality of educational research, in terms of its scientific rigour, its utility for practitioners and the manner in which it is assessed. This study addresses the reasons why the quality of educational research was questioned, and then examines the discussion framework for assessing quality which emerged. Following from this, the merits of possible internal and external criteria for the worth of educational research are considered. The links between these criterial sets and the function and purpose of qualitative and quantitative approaches to educational research are analysed. Finally, the question of whether educational research is an art or a science is addressed.
Keywords:criterial judgements educational research, bmjnyp, bmjlink
Subjects:X Education > X300 Academic studies in Education
Divisions:College of Social Science > Centre for Educational Research & Development (CERD)
ID Code:2991
Deposited By: Terence Karran
Deposited On:20 Jul 2010 15:01
Last Modified:13 Mar 2013 08:42

Repository Staff Only: item control page