Use of lithium tracers to quantify drilling fluid contamination for groundwater monitoring in Southeast Asia

Richards, Laura A. and Magnone, Daniel and van Dongen, Bart E. and Ballentine, Christopher J. and Polya, David A. (2015) Use of lithium tracers to quantify drilling fluid contamination for groundwater monitoring in Southeast Asia. Applied Geochemistry, 63 . pp. 190-202. ISSN 0883-2927

Full content URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeochem.2015.08.013

DocumentsOthers
1-s2.0-S0883292715300305-main.pdf
[img]
[Download]
[img] HTML
S0883292715300305

55kB
[img]
Preview
PDF
1-s2.0-S0883292715300305-main.pdf - Whole Document
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.

942kB
Item Type:Article
Item Status:Live Archive

Abstract

Drilling is widely used in groundwater monitoring and many other applications but has the inherent problem of introducing some degree of external contamination into the natural systems being monitored. Contamination from drilling fluid is particularly problematic for (i) wells with relatively low water flow rates which are difficult to flush; and for (ii) hydrogeochemical research studies of groundwaters hosted by incompletely consolidated shallow sediments, which are widely utilized as sources of drinking water and irrigation water across many parts of Asia. Here, we develop and evaluate a method that can be simply used to quantify the extent of drilling fluid contribution to a water sample either to optimize sample collection for reduced contamination, or to allow a correction for contamination to be made. We report the utility of lithium chloride tracers using both field and laboratory analytical techniques to quantitatively evaluate and correct for drilling fluid contamination of casing waters through an investigation of 15 sites in Kandal Province, Cambodia. High analytical errors limit the practicality and resolution of field-based lithium ion selective electrode measurements for purposes other than broad estimates of gross contamination. However, when laboratory analysis is integrated with the method (e.g. via inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry analysis), lithium tracers can provide a robust and accurate method for evaluating drilling-related contamination if appropriate samples are collected. Casing water is susceptible to contamination from drilling fluid which was shown to be significantly reduced within two to three well volumes of flushing but can still persist above background for greater than seven well volumes of flushing. A waiting period after drilling and prior to water sampling was shown to further decrease contamination due to dilution from the surrounding aquifer, particularly in more permeable wells. Contamination values were generally <3% for 34 monitoring wells across 15 sites after flushing a mean of 4.6 ± 3.8 well volumes, even when lithium-spiked water was directly injected during flushing to remove settled mud/debris. Operational issues can be encountered which can (i) lead to contamination being much higher than the mean if wells are highly unproductive and clay-dominated or (ii) lead to higher flushing volumes than the mean particularly in sandy areas where fine sand may enter the well screening. General correction factors have been provided for typical monitoring wells in poorly consolidated shallow aquifers in Southeast Asia, and examples provided for how to correct other groundwater data for contamination. For most analytes such as sodium or dissolved organic carbon (DOC), specific corrections may not be necessary for the typical magnitude of contamination encountered, particularly when the differences in concentrations between the drilling fluid and groundwater are relatively small. In the particular circumstance where drilling fluid may have much higher DOC than groundwaters, or vice versa with drilling fluid having much lower DOC than groundwaters in organic-rich alluvial sediments, corrections may still be necessary and significant. Similarly, for highly sensitive parameters such as 14C model age or other age-related parameters (such as tritium, chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) or sulfur hexafluoride (SF6)), corrections can be significant in typical field scenarios particularly when contamination values are high and/or there is a large difference in age between groundwater and drilling fluid. The lithium method was verified with comparison to changes in concentration of a suite of representative and naturally occurring groundwater constituents as a function of well flushing from relatively low and high permeability groundwater monitoring wells to further illustrate the technique.

Additional Information:Open Access funded by Natural Environment Research Council Under a Creative Commons license CC-BY-4.0
Keywords:Chemical tracers, Lithium, Drilling fluid, Groundwater, Monitoring well contamination, NotOAChecked
Subjects:F Physical Sciences > F851 Applied Environmental Sciences
F Physical Sciences > F140 Environmental Chemistry
F Physical Sciences > F850 Environmental Sciences
F Physical Sciences > F852 Hydrology
Divisions:College of Science > School of Geography
ID Code:28119
Deposited On:04 Aug 2017 10:25

Repository Staff Only: item control page